By Emmanuel Ogbodo
A Federal High Court in Abuja has denied a motion filed by Nigeria’s Inspector General of Police (IGP) that sought to compel 12 banks and financial institutions to reverse billions of naira allegedly fraudulently withdrawn from a Flutterwave account at Wema Bank, according to a report by Nairametrics. The withdrawals reportedly resulted from a system glitch between October 12 and 13, 2023.
In the motion ex parte, dated July 17, 2024, and marked FHC/ABJ/CS/1015/24, the IGP’s legal team argued that approximately 244 suspects had criminally syphoned billions from Flutterwave’s account, transferring the funds to numerous bank accounts belonging to individuals who are either untraceable or difficult to locate.
During Wednesday’s proceedings, the Inspector General’s counsel, Victor Okoye, urged Justice Peter Lifu to grant the motion ex parte and order the reversal of the funds to Flutterwave, in line with relevant legal provisions. However, Justice Lifu questioned the rationale behind granting the motion without hearing from the respondents, including the banks and suspects, citing the constitutional requirement for fair hearing.
“Should I order the banks to reverse the funds without hearing their side of the story, based on your one-sided account? If I grant the reversal, what is left of this case? You did not file a motion on notice. Once I reverse it, that is the end of the matter,” the judge said, emphasising the importance of a fair hearing, particularly from the banks involved.
In response, the IGP’s counsel argued that the defendants were untraceable but could approach the court when ready. However, Justice Lifu countered by noting that the banks, as entities responsible for reversing the funds, should have been served with legal processes to allow them to respond. The judge also pointed out that there was no motion on notice accompanying the ex parte motion, as required by the court’s rules.
“Who is to reverse it if not the banks? Serve them and let them come and tell me, ‘We surrender, we have no objection, and we are ready to comply with the court order,’” Justice Lifu remarked.
Subsequently, the judge refused the ex parte motion, describing it as a clear violation of Section 36 of the 1999 Constitution, which guarantees the right to a fair hearing.
Earlier reports indicated that Flutterwave had lost N11 billion due to a security breach. The company later confirmed that the incident occurred in April 2023 when it detected unusual activity on one of its platforms, which is used by a small number of customers for specific business transactions. Flutterwave stated that the heist was ultimately unsuccessful, as it swiftly alerted law enforcement and provided the IP addresses and details of the offenders.
However, court documents revealed that Flutterwave had sought police assistance to recover the stolen funds rather than focusing solely on prosecuting the offenders. Preliminary police investigations indicated that fraudulent transactions were conducted using Flutterwave POS terminals on October 12 and 13, 2023.
Following these revelations, Flutterwave requested that Wema Bank immediately freeze its settlement account, from which large sums had been transferred to various individual bank accounts. Data from the Nigeria Inter-Bank Settlement System (NIBSS) also revealed that 9,633 erroneous transactions were made on the Flutterwave POS platform during the system glitch, involving 814 Flutterwave POS agents.
NIBSS estimated Flutterwave’s total exposure at the time to be N21.2 billion, but the company worked with banks to restrict affected accounts, successfully preserving N7.2 billion. The IGP noted that his team had eventually arrested some of the suspected POS agents involved in the fraudulent activities.
Flutterwave is not alone in experiencing significant losses due to fraud. A report by the Financial Institutions Training Centre (FITC) revealed that Nigerian banks lost N2.09 billion to fraud in Q4 2023 alone, with mobile channels being the primary method used by criminals. In 2022, MTN, Africa’s largest mobile network operator, lost N10.5 billion to cybercriminals.