Connect with us

Judiciary

Appeal Court Overturns Dr Oladele’s Conviction in Landmark Ruling on Sexual Assault Case

Published

on

By Adenike Lawal

In a landmark legal ruling, the Lagos Division of the Appeal Court has overturned the conviction of Dr. Olufemi Olaleye on charges of defilement and sexual assault by penetration.

This judgment follows a previous conviction by Justice Rahman Oshodi of the High Court of Lagos State on October 24, 2023.

The Appeal Court’s decision, delivered on Friday, marks a significant turning point in this high-profile case.

The appeal, heard on September 24, 2024, was led by Dr. Kemi Pinheiro, SAN, with a team of lawyers representing Dr. Olaleye.

The three-member panel, presided over by Hon. Justice Jimi Bada, unanimously ruled in favor of the appellant, resolving all five issues raised by the defense team.

A key element of the court’s ruling was the prosecution’s failure to conclusively establish the age of the alleged victim.

The court pointed out that determining whether the victim was underage, specifically 16 years old, could not be definitively determined based solely on visual observations made during testimony.

The Appeal Court also criticized the trial court for admitting statements allegedly made by Dr. Olaleye without conducting a trial-within-a-trial to determine whether the statements were made voluntarily.

The court found this oversight to be detrimental to the prosecution’s case, particularly as Dr. Olaleye had claimed that the statements were obtained under duress.

Additionally, the court highlighted the lack of credible evidence from the prosecution’s six witnesses. Mrs. Aderemi Olaleye, who testified against her husband as PW1, was deemed a “tainted witness.”

The court noted that her testimony was likely motivated by financial gain and her desire to take control of Dr. Olaleye’s assets while he was incarcerated.

The medical testimony presented during the trial was also called into question by the Appeal Court, which deemed it unreliable and impeached.

In addressing concerns about judicial conduct, the court expressed serious reservations about the trial judge’s level of involvement, suggesting that it may have compromised the fairness and impartiality of the trial.

Based on these findings, the Lagos Division of the Appeal Court acquitted and discharged Dr. Olufemi Olaleye, overturning his previous conviction and highlighting significant procedural flaws in the handling of his case at trial.

This ruling not only underscores critical issues regarding evidentiary standards in sexual assault cases but also raises important questions about judicial practices and witness credibility in high-profile legal battles.

 

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Judiciary

Chamber Commissioning: Every Empire Will Expire, Akintola Tells Nigerian Leaders

Published

on

By

By Samson Adeyanju

A Senior Advocate of Nigeria, Chief Adeniyi Akintola, has cautioned Nigerian leaders and public office holders against abusing power, stressing that no position of authority or political influence is permanent.

Akintola gave the warning at the commissioning of Dayo Ajibola & Associates, also known as SBA Chambers, where he urged those in positions of authority to remain humble, remember their roots and prepare for life after office.

“Every empire will expire. Let those who are holding public office get this into their heads. Every empire will expire. Every person in a position of authority will come to a time when he will no longer be relevant,” he said.

The legal practitioner also warned politicians against sacrificing people for political interests, urging professionals who interact with political leaders to be cautious and maintain clear boundaries between their principles and political relationships.

He said money should not be allowed to determine a person’s values or professional decisions, urging young lawyers to resist the temptation of seeking immediate financial rewards.

According to him, younger lawyers should focus on building credibility, relationships and professional competence rather than demanding large fees from every client.

“The younger generation lawyers are making the mistake of wanting that money now, now, now. It doesn’t work that way,” Akintola said.

He advised lawyers to carefully assess the clients they represent and avoid fraudulent individuals and activities.

“We have a standard in our office. No room for 419,” he said, stressing that professional reputation remained more valuable than short term financial gains.

Akintola further urged young professionals not to live beyond their means, saying proper financial planning was necessary for sustainable careers and businesses.

He explained that his law office makes provisions for the maintenance and replacement of office equipment, noting that professionals must plan for unforeseen expenses instead of spending all their earnings.

“If you take good care of your job, your job will take good care of you,” he said.

The Senior Advocate also emphasised discipline and commitment to legal practice, particularly punctuality and diligence in handling clients’ briefs.

“The court will not wait for you. You should be in court latest by 8:30. The client that gives you a brief is not waiting for stories. He wants results,” he said.

Akintola urged senior lawyers to continue mentoring younger practitioners and advised employees to remain loyal and committed to their employers.

He also encouraged the new generation to remain prayerful, disciplined and patient, saying genuine professional success is built over time.

Speaking at the occasion, Senator Abdulfatai Buhari, representing Oyo North Senatorial District, commended Akintola for his commitment to mentoring younger professionals.

Buhari, who said he had adjusted his international travel plans to attend the event, congratulated Dayo Ajibola on the commissioning of the chambers.

He said the presence of senior practitioners and other distinguished personalities at the event demonstrated the respect Akintola had earned through his character and professional relationships.

Buhari urged Akintola to remain focused despite betrayal, blackmail and disappointment, saying the growth of people he had mentored should give him satisfaction.

“People will still continue to betray. People will continue to blackmail. People will continue to misbehave, but just be happy that the people you are training are coming up, and you are seeing them growing,” he said.

In his vote of thanks, Barrister Dayo Ajibola, principal of the newly commissioned chambers, expressed appreciation to Akintola, senior lawyers, public officials, friends and other guests for honouring the occasion.

Ajibola, who became emotional while recounting some of the challenges he had overcome, attributed his survival and progress in life to God’s protection, prayers and the support of family, mentors and friends.

He disclosed that he had obtained bachelor’s and master’s degrees before returning to study law, describing his journey into the legal profession as one marked by several challenges and near tragedies.

Ajibola thanked Akintola for his mentorship and described his presence at the commissioning as a significant honour.

He also expressed appreciation to the senior members of the legal profession who attended the ceremony, saying their support had encouraged him to continue building the new law firm.

The commissioning marked a significant milestone for Dayo Ajibola & Associates and brought together members of the legal profession, political figures, friends and associates.

Continue Reading

Judiciary

BREAKING: Judge Withdraws from El-Rufai’s Fundamental Rights Suit

Published

on

By

By Olokuta Rofiat

A judge of the FCT High Court has withdrawn from the fundamental rights enforcement suit filed by former Kaduna State Governor, Nasir El-Rufai.

Justice Hussaini Belgore recused himself from the matter on Friday for undisclosed reasons, paving the way for the case to be reassigned and delaying further proceedings.

El-Rufai had sued the Independent Corrupt Practices and Other Related Offences Commission, the Inspector-General of Police and others, alleging a violation of his constitutional rights following the search of his Abuja residence. He is seeking damages and declarations that his rights were breached.

Separately, the Department of State Services has filed criminal charges against him at the Federal High Court in Abuja over alleged unlawful interception of communications. The case was adjourned to April 23, 2026.

Legal observers say reassignment of the fundamental rights suit may take weeks before hearings resume.

Continue Reading

Judiciary

El-Rufai Drags ICPC to Court, Demands N1bn Compensation

Published

on

By

By Patrick Idowu

Former Kaduna State Governor Nasir El-Rufai has filed a N1 billion lawsuit against the Independent Corrupt Practices and Other Related Offences Commission (ICPC), following an allegedly unlawful raid on his Abuja residence.

Through his lead counsel, Oluwole Iyamu, SAN, El-Rufai is asking the court to invalidate a February 4 search warrant issued by an FCT Magistrate’s Court, citing material drafting errors, ambiguity, and a lack of probable cause.

He contends that the execution of the warrant violated his constitutional rights under Section 37, rendering any evidence obtained during the search inadmissible in future proceedings.

The former governor is seeking an injunction to bar the ICPC from utilizing any seized items and is demanding heavy financial restitution for the encounter.

His N1 billion claim includes N300 million for psychological trauma, N400 million in exemplary damages to deter law enforcement misconduct, and N300 million in aggravated damages for the “malicious and high-handed” nature of the operation.

Additionally, El-Rufai is requesting N100 million to cover his legal fees and the overall cost of the litigation.

Continue Reading

Trending